What's a non colored headphone? A headphone that masks all recordings equally? There is certainly an aspect to detail retrieval related to driver capability independent of FR bias. If someone can't tell 128kb from 320kb (assuming a properly dynamic track) that phone/rig is masking and simply not accurate.
How about the references to location in the audience that people frequently use? Can't remember the exact phrasing. But I often read people placing headphones in a very precise location in an audience. Like "the Grados man, I love them cause they put me ON the stage man, the ATH's are like 4 rows back, and the HD650 is just boring, it's way in the back of the concert hall and I just fall asleep". I'm always thinking ...."what?" What the hell does that mean? Maybe I haven't been to enough concerts or something I don't know, it just seems like BS to me.
(it's way too easy to translate pompous audiophile to stonerspeak)
So basically, WTH does that mean precisely? Especially when we are tying to communicate sonic qualities to someone else (not an easy task!) One is better of simply saying that one prefers the MadDog over the Paradox. In other words, the term "musical" without the support of any further elaboration is really the ultimate cop-out when we think about it.