I have an album full of them over on HF if you want to browse...
This album is not creepy at all.
It would be cute if they weren't sexualized. Anime girls with the short skirts and curvy bodies and huge child like eyes = creepy.
In the Western world there are pin-ups, Asia and Japan in particular has the "fan service." I grew up with comics and I agree that the over-sexualisation of women is disturbing. The same applies for men in comics and animation if you ask me.People and cultures have their preferences and opinions. At one point the "fan service" stops being tasteful and becomes a reason to avoid anime until something really good comes up again like Code Geass or Attack on Titan.
But instinctually, viscerally, when you see a hyper-sexualized female form attached to a child's face it is just disturbing.