^This. Tires almost greater than everything else. Have a problem you want resolved? Look at your tires first then elsewhere.
in other news, I am considering seriously to get rid of my 1996 Subaru outback. nearing 200k (240k on the motor, an EJ22)Possible replacements include Honda Element, Honda Ridgeline and on the other spectrum a Prius
Almost. Getting off the line, AWD on all-seasons will still beat RWD on snows. Otherwise AWD only has an advantage when on the power, for obvious reasons. Even then, implementation is key. There's a great video that Matt Farah did driving an M235xi around a soaking wet track, and it's handling is complete and utter dog shit. An S4 would NOT be totally out of shape like that.
Why not the Focus?
I am burning through 250-300$ in gas every month. The way I drive, both my current cars don't do any better than 20MPG for the outback and 24 for the GT86. Main downside of the prius, well other than being a prius is you can't tow anything with it (insurance won't cover if you get into an accident towing it). I need to be able to transport a dirt bike or a street bike every so often.
yeah, but i already have one fun car. i don't want to end up with 3 vehicles, a truck, a fun car and a commuter