the problem here is that the question will always yield different responses depending on who you ask.
For that reason there will never be a satisfactory answer to everyone.
The main 'problem' is here that people mix up
power and
voltage.
Most headphones do not need a lot of power (check my table:
http://www.mediafire.com/view/dzwe1g73q6pbhnx/headphone%20power%20table.pdf).
Only very few inefficient ones do and don't even need that much as people think.
It doesn't hurt to have a lot of
power available
unless you are using headphones that cannot handle a lot of
power.
In this case you run the risk of burning out the voice coils by accident (when not on the head) but will never run into clipping.
Having a surplus in power of a factor 10 won't hurt but will never be used, but also will never have to worry about possible clipping.
Having too little power (
voltage actually) won't damage any voicecoils but higher impedance headphones won't reach decent SPL levels.
Driving an HD800 or HD600 from a Sansa clip won't give a satisfactory sound simply because the output voltage clips before a decent level is reached.
IF you only like to play it softly there is no problem.
People draw the conclusion they need more
power.
They DO of course as power is related to voltage (P (watt) = U
2(voltage) x impedance (Ohm)) but what they really need is more
voltageBecause of these facts the myth is born 'more power = better sound'.
It has
some truth in it though.
Having an amp that can deliver 10W, if your headphone can only handle 0.2W, won't sound better than when playing it from an amp that can deliver 1W.
Of course you also need to include the psycholgical factor of having the 'knowledge' the amp will never reach its limits and you have 'power' in your hands.
For instance, an amp may deliver
1W into 16 Ohm but into 600 Ohm the
same amp will only deliver
0.025W (assuming the current limit is not reached and output resistance is low)
Someone that THINKS he just bought a powerfull amp (it is 1W for heavens sake!) will not drive a 600 Ohm very loud.
So.. he thinks.. I need a much
more powerfull amp.
He doesn't, he just needs a higher output voltage.
He could play it loud on an amp with a very low output
power but with a high output
voltage (and thus little current)
It works the other way around too.
An amplifier that can deliver
1W into 600 Ohm only needs to deliver 40mA (60mA pk) to achieve that power.
Lets assume it is current limited to 60mA.
When you connect a 20 Ohm headphone to that
same amp it will only deliver
0.032W into it.
VERY few amps will deliver the same wattage into a wide range of impedances.
Most amps are current limited or have a limited output voltage swing or both (C'Moys for instance)
Power specs are
MEANINGLESS unless they are accompanied by the headphone impedances that it must drive.
This too adds to the power confusion on the web.
Manufacturers do like to 'list' numbers and so they list the highest number.
This is just the
technical part though, as many will say that doesn't account for everything that is perceived.