CHANGSTAR: Audiophile Headphone Reviews and Early 90s Style BBS

Lobby => Speakers => Topic started by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 03:30:57 AM

Title: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 03:30:57 AM
I'm figur'n on getting some 'better' mini-monitors to replace my $40 Dayton B652's (mod'd & upgraded)

Once my Rok shows up and settles in, then the finalists in my search can be evaluated.

So who has any reccomnedations?

My short list thus far includes just 2 candidates
The KEF LS50
The Ascend Acoustics Sierra 2

Has anyone compared these 2 monitors with each other?
They both have several design aspects that set off my curiosity alarms, most notably is their use of 'customized' drivers developed just for these speakers, not to mention their measured behaviors.

Any other candidates I should add to this list?


JJ
Title: Re: $1000+ for mini monitors…
Post by: zerodeefex on November 10, 2014, 03:37:54 AM
What do you consider mini?
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 03:54:57 AM
'Bookshelf' sized.

I have some leeway in terms of placement and can accommodate a range of sizes.


JJ
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: thegunner100 on November 10, 2014, 04:03:23 AM
Wanna buy both and compare them for us? ;D

Those two would be my picks as well, if I had the money to buy them, space to put them, and time to listen to them.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Greed on November 10, 2014, 04:17:43 AM
I caved and bought a pair of Sierra 2 speakers when massdrop was hosting them. I was really close to pulling the trigger on a pair of LS50 after hearing them 3-4 times at shows and demos at my local dealer. I'll let you know what I think of the two in comparison when I get the Sierra 2s.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: lmswjm on November 10, 2014, 04:18:36 AM
The Vapor Breeze would be close to that price category. I went with the Fritz 5 SE because it I needed a smaller cabinet for my workstation. No Rag yet though

I have a feeling though that the Philharmonitor might be the best bang for the buck though.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 04:24:24 AM

I caved and bought a pair of Sierra 2 speakers when massdrop was hosting them. I was really close to pulling the trigger on a pair of LS50 after hearing them 3-4 times at shows and demos at my local dealer. I'll let you know what I think of the two in comparison when I get the Sierra 2s.

Excellent!
I look forward to reading your findings. :thumb

I did find this one review, which is ongoing…
http://emotivalounge.proboards.com/thread/39246/ls50-ascend-acoustics-sierra-loudspeakers (http://emotivalounge.proboards.com/thread/39246/ls50-ascend-acoustics-sierra-loudspeakers)
The guy does seem to have decent set of ears since he hears subtle differences based upon program material.

JJ


Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 05:19:56 AM
Wanna buy both and compare them for us? ;D

Those two would be my picks as well, if I had the money to buy them, space to put them, and time to listen to them.
Right now my entire computer speaker system cost less than buying a set of 'computer speakers', even with the $25 tweeter up grade…   hahahahahaha

I figure the upgrade from a $20 Lepai amp to the Rok will force my hand with these really quite decent, cheap speakers.  Although it will be interesting to hear what the differences will actually be.

It will also be interesting to see how close speakers, in a near field setting, will approach what my 800's provide, especially since they both will be driven by the same source(s).
An interesting experiment…


JJ
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: LFF on November 10, 2014, 07:10:00 AM
Awesome "bookshelf" speakers for under $1000


1. Start up computer
2. Google "Used Mackie HR824"
3. Find pair in good condition for $500
4. Buy them
5. ENJOY!  :)p1
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: johnjen on November 10, 2014, 07:19:52 AM
snip

I have a feeling though that the Philharmonitor might be the best bang for the buck though.
  It seems that the Philharmonitor is a 'joint venture' with
http://www.alexissound.com (http://www.alexissound.com)

An interesting choice to be sure.

JJ
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: donunus on November 10, 2014, 09:48:56 AM
I liked the Sonus Faber concertinos when I heard them late 90s. Dont know if they still exist or the newer versions if still available will sound the same.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Hroðulf on November 10, 2014, 10:19:16 AM
Having recently looked through many studio monitor in-room measurements, it seems for me that usually room acoustics have much larger role to play in the resulting sound signature, than actual model differences.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Priidik on November 10, 2014, 11:15:05 AM
Used Mini Genelecs  :wheel:
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: shipsupt on November 10, 2014, 01:02:33 PM
Awesome "bookshelf" speakers for under $1000


1. Start up computer
2. Google "Used Mackie HR824"
3. Find pair in good condition for $500
4. Buy them
5. ENJOY!  :)p1

Are the MK 2's OK or did they screw 'em up?

Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: firev1 on November 10, 2014, 04:12:53 PM
Used Mini Genelecs  :wheel:

Still my dream speakers aside from Full range bookshelves. Their construction is pretty insane.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 05:19:55 PM
The Vapor Breeze would be close to that price category. I went with the Fritz 5 SE because it I needed a smaller cabinet for my workstation. No Rag yet though

I have a feeling though that the Philharmonitor might be the best bang for the buck though.

It was, but with the new cabinet design the Breeze got a lot more expensive. It's now knocking on the door of $2K. The downside of the Phil compared to the Ascend is that Fountek. When it comes to ribbon tweeters, there's RAAL, and then there's the rest.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 05:22:24 PM
Awesome "bookshelf" speakers for under $1000


1. Start up computer
2. Google "Used Mackie HR824"

Using low grade studio monitor amps when you have a Ragnarok sitting there seems like kind of a waste. If one does want to go that route though, Neumann > Mackie. Hard.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 05:40:58 PM
Regarding the OPs original question, I don't think either is a bad choice. The Ascend has a little more extension (about 5Hz or so) and would probably be my choice at normal listening distances, but in nearfield setup, the KEF's concentric driver advantages and wave guide may give it the edge. I haven't heard either of them in that context. Speakers that sound like a single point source at 8 feet may start to sound like two individual drivers at 2 feet.

There are PLENTY of other choices out there, particularly if you include Audiogon, so I wouldn't just stop at those two. The first I would highly recommend considering is Odyssey's new Epiphony IV, which is right at the $1K mark. Then, for under $1.5K right now there are listings for a pair of Reference 3A Dulcet Bes which is an excellent little speaker for desktop use, in fact that's probably the prime use for it. There's also a couple of pairs of Merlin TSM-MXEs which has long been one of my favorite monitors.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: ultrabike on November 10, 2014, 05:50:00 PM
Though $1k is not a price I like, of all the stuff mentioned here I have only listened to the LS50s and loved what I heard (relative to random stuff here and there), so I would recommend those.

Mackie's are indeed active monitors which will not use the power of the one Rag. However, to me it seems like an excelent recommendation, coming from someone with ample experiense. Dunno what makes it's internal amplification low grade, or in what ways Neumann > Mackie.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Elysian on November 10, 2014, 06:54:11 PM
How do the LS50s compare to Mini Maggies? I really enjoyed the Mini Maggies but they are so temperamental about positioning.

With the perfect physical setup, they sound great, but move off by just a foot and the illusion all falls apart.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: ultrabike on November 10, 2014, 07:00:31 PM
I don't think I heard the Mini Maggies. But did hear the Maggie room at THE Show (they had some full pannel ones, dunno the exact model). Liked the LS50s better.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 07:17:36 PM
Mackie's are indeed active monitors which will not use the power of the one Rag. However, to me it seems like an excelent recommendation, coming from someone with ample experiense. Dunno what makes it's internal amplification low grade, or in what ways Neumann > Mackie.

It's not the kind of junk you'll find on the back of a consumer grade active monitor, but these amps are just not a match for an amp like the Ragnarok. Given the space and budget constraints Mackie has to work within in order for these things to retail at $700/ea, it means they are putting together an amp, cabinet, and drivers for what, $200? That's probably being generous.

IME the Mackies have some grain in the upper/mid treble region that makes them less than fantastic, though they aren't as grating as some of the Yamahas. The Neumanns are no match for the elite class of monitors that you can't order online (and that all cost several thousand dollars), but at their price level they are among the very best that I've heard.

(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-g0uN0JzE1lo/TdSlbOCIj5I/AAAAAAAAA2U/Wb70byXSht4/s1600/hr824.jpg)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: OJneg on November 10, 2014, 07:22:08 PM
Which Neumanns? We have a pair of those Mackie monitors at work and I know they are quite good.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 07:27:00 PM
KH120. It's a 5" not an 8" so it obviously doesn't have the extension that the 824 does. Sounds much better though to my ears, and that's what I would tell anyone to buy who's looking for a pair of $1500 actives.

The KH 310 midfield is right up there with its old K+H forebear, and it DOES play with the big boys. It's also $5K/pr.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on November 10, 2014, 08:18:44 PM
FWIW, a review of the old version of the Dulcet vs. a bunch of other monitors including pricey Dynaudios and B&Ws.

http://www.tnt-audio.com/casse/ref3a_dulcet_e.html (http://www.tnt-audio.com/casse/ref3a_dulcet_e.html)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: eddypoon on January 10, 2015, 09:41:12 AM
interested in, if any, more opinions on ls50.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: hendric0 on January 10, 2015, 11:54:56 AM
I would consider Adam A5x(has ribbon tweeter, btw) or the smaller Genelecs. They say that smaller Genelecs sound as good as the bigger ones, bass is rolled of earlier. (Edit: by smaller i mean smaller 8000 series monitors)

Haven't heard Adams, they are often compared to Genelcs and Klein+Hummel, but they cost less.

I would not consider cheaper Mackies. We did a test in project room, with speakers flush-mounted in a granite wall, Genelec 8050A vs Mackies. So it was, all speaker, less acoustic disturbances. Mackies lacked detail, extremly boomy, uncontrolled, but also weak bass for a monitor(dynamics). Did not go down low. Mackies were 8'', can't remeber the model. (they were not their higher end line, i think).
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: TiFrameLock on January 28, 2015, 07:22:12 PM
The NHT Class Three is still a great choice in for about $900...if you're looking to stay below $1000. 
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: OJneg on January 28, 2015, 08:28:01 PM
Oh BTW, JBL LSR308 is amaze-balls. Destroys any equivalently priced monitor from Yamaha, KRK and the likes. I wouldn't be surprised if it took down some opposition in the 4 figures either.

Definitely not a "mini" monitor though
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Thad E Ginathom on January 29, 2015, 09:52:01 AM
They say that smaller Genelecs sound as good as the bigger ones, bass is rolled of earlier.

Genelec say so. They say that the entire range has the same sound signature, making it possible, for instance, to replace one of a pair, and still have a matched pair. The difference between models is in how low they go and how loud they go.

I suspect that they are not the only studio monitor manufacturer to make this claim. It may be a necessary, especially as studio monitors tend to be sold in singles, not pairs.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Priidik on February 06, 2015, 03:36:13 PM
Genelec say so. They say that the entire range has the same sound signature, making it possible, for instance, to replace one of a pair, and still have a matched pair. The difference between models is in how low they go and how loud they go.

I can second that. I heard their smaller and largest in egg-shaped versions in a shop. Tonally really similar.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Thad E Ginathom on February 06, 2015, 04:49:49 PM
Also, of course, add extra channels with matched sound signatures.

I forgot that bit, probably because I only ever think in stereo  :)p17
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: hendric0 on February 08, 2015, 11:36:59 AM
An  observation: high-end subwoofer(i heard a 10'' Genelec sub) do add to the lower end, somewhat. Even 6.5'' driver can have Proper amount of bass in the lower range when you have thick walls around it, but believable slam and grunt is an other thing.

On the technical side of monitors. Genelec 8050A seems to use STK442-130 integrated amp. I have heard that it is important to optimize these to the speaker system. So they can sound good. I wonder what Neumann KH uses. I have heard that they have 'special' midrange, some prefer them to other monitors, they are great with vocals etc.

Genelec PCB looks like this:(http://imagizer.imageshack.us/v2/150x100q90/822/photoon20120208at22112.jpg) (http://imageshack.com/f/muphotoon20120208at22112j)


 
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: hendric0 on February 08, 2015, 12:03:37 PM
Oh BTW, JBL LSR308 is amaze-balls. Destroys any equivalently priced monitor from Yamaha, KRK and the likes. I wouldn't be surprised if it took down some opposition in the 4 figures either.

Definitely not a "mini" monitor though

These look interesting. JBL also has somekind of high end model in the making, and the LSR308 are inspired by it. What models did you compare them to?
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 13, 2015, 07:41:58 PM
Does anyone have an opinion on the Focal Solo/Twin 6? 

I'm looking to get a nice pair of studio monitors with the intent of using them to improve (or flat out fix) the EQ on my needledrops of old/poorly mastered latin recordings.

My room is pretty small; the speakers will be up against a wall with the opposite wall about 9 ft away and my seating distance will be about 4ft from the speakers.  I live in a condo so performance/resolution at moderate volume is important to me.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on April 13, 2015, 09:24:32 PM
Does anyone have an opinion on the Focal Solo/Twin 6? 

I'm looking to get a nice pair of studio monitors with the intent of using them to improve (or flat out fix) the EQ on my needledrops of old/poorly mastered latin recordings.

My room is pretty small; the speakers will be up against a wall with the opposite wall about 9 ft away and my seating distance will be about 4ft from the speakers.  I live in a condo so performance/resolution at moderate volume is important to me.

Not a fan. I've always found Focals of all stripes to be vastly overpriced and generally unpleasant to listen to for any length of time. The Event Opal on the other hand is a VERY nice pro monitor. Above that, I'd be looking at PMC, ATC, or some of the more esoteric stuff that you have to get from specialized dealers. I'm far from an expert on those, but there are plenty of folks on boards like gearslutz that can steer you in the right direction.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 14, 2015, 05:06:24 PM
Thanks for the lead. :)

I started my research last night; looks like the Focals are a "mid forward"/slightly bright speaker which is absolutely not what I want.  My reading impressions are that the Opals are more laid back up top but still very resolving. 

As time goes on and I learn more I think that I am discovering that my preferences lean towards a more "laid back" signature most of the time because I find that I am more sensitive then more to abnormalities in the mid/treble region and there is simply soooo much good but poorly mastered/recorded music out there.  My hearing is still good to 17KHz, 18KHz at very loud volume...

BH Photo has a sweet deal on a pair of opals that includes an isolation platform, 1/4" to xlr cables (mogami 2534/neutrik) and free shipping to Canada for $3K USD. So tempting.... might bite.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 20, 2015, 03:20:28 PM
Ordered a pair of Opals + stands from a Canadian distributor.  My room is completely untreated (and small :/) so I guess step one is to figure out how bad it is and then order up appropriate acoustic treatments.  Looking forward to it!  I've been using some Boston Acoustics computer monitors from circa 2003 as my speaker setup in this room so this will be just a weeeeeeee step up :)p13
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on April 20, 2015, 11:41:41 PM
Ordered a pair of Opals + stands from a Canadian distributor.  My room is completely untreated (and small :/) so I guess step one is to figure out how bad it is and then order up appropriate acoustic treatments.  Looking forward to it!  I've been using some Boston Acoustics computer monitors from circa 2003 as my speaker setup in this room so this will be just a weeeeeeee step up :)p13

Yeah this should be a bit of an improvement. While you wait, get in touch with GIK Acoustics and let them know your room setup and what you want to do. They don't charge for consultations like some other companies, and they'll help you plan on where you want to go first with treatments.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 21, 2015, 02:01:26 AM
That sounds like a very good idea.

My computer/music room sits in the middle of my condo and is about 8'x13' which is really small. Even worse I will almost certainly have to put the speakers on the long wall because the short side has a window on one end and door on the other.   The only good news is that the floor is carpeted and the walls are drywall which is not a hard surface.

I've never used any room EQ software like REW or studio EQ so I have much much reading and learning to do.  Probably will spend some time getting comfortable with taking measurements and learn enough to make semi-intelligent conversation on the topic.

Absolute worst case I stick them in my living room :)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on April 21, 2015, 04:04:38 AM
I think it's possible to make a room like that work... at least above 50Hz or so. Where you're likely to run into serious problems is with low frequencies. Using big tri-traps in the corners is probably where I'd start to try and get the bass under some degree of control. Definitely what you're going to want to do when you have the speakers is start measuring the room response.

EQ is great for taking out peaks, not so great for dealing with nulls. If you have a huge suckout in bass for example, trying to deal with it using EQ will just overdrive the amp.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 21, 2015, 04:03:50 PM
Yep, exactly.  I'm hoping my position will not incur some kind of huge null.  If it's really awful I could even put the monitors on one of the short sides of the room (I bought 36" stands) and simply turn my chair to listen.  Might even try that first since it doesn't require me to move any furniture. :)

Another small bonus is that my condo building was built in 1978 (first in the city) and due to the thick concrete between floors/units there is very good sound isolation from other units.  Extra bonus I have an end unit so I am even more isolated.  As long as I can mostly tame the bass nodes I should be able to turn it up pretty loud when needed without seriously pissing anyone off.   headbang

Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 23, 2015, 02:29:21 AM
So today Purolator shows up and kindly drops stuff off at the (24/7) security desk for me because I was at work.  I show up after work to discover that I got the stands, studio eq package and.... ONE speaker. WTF?  Freaked me out till I checked online to discover that the other speaker was still in transit.   

Not content to wait around for tomorrow the obvious the solution was to plant the thing in the middle of my living room and hook myself up with some mono goodness  :)p13

The speaker is still breaking in but first impression is extremely positive.  Tone is really spot on and detail/resolution is incredible.  Put my needledrop of the AP Miles Davis 'Cookin reissue on and it's niiiiiiiiice.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 23, 2015, 06:59:37 PM
OK time for me to stop derailing this thread and steer things back on track so here is a super cool resource I discovered the other day where you can find recordings of 55 different studio monitors of all price ranges:
https://soundcloud.com/sonic-sense-pro-audio/sets/studio-monitors

Recording methodology can be found this video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EAFBysViAg

You can also download the original 24 bit recordings since soundcloud compresses everything to 128Kbps.

Obviously the output is going to be colored by your playback system; still I think you can get a pretty decent picture of how the various monitors sound.  Very cool.



Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on April 23, 2015, 08:26:16 PM
Obviously the output is going to be colored by your playback system; still I think you can get a pretty decent picture of how the various monitors sound.  Very cool.

It's a clever idea, but I don't think they could've picked a worse sample track if they tried. I get that it probably has to be public domain music, but still.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on April 24, 2015, 04:07:16 PM
Yeah, I don't really see how I am supposed to evaluate the synth and mostly electronic instruments that dominate the track... How is it supposed to sound?  It's not like there is a reference or anything... 

Would have strongly preferred something acoustic.  Still, I think it's a pretty cool resource.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on April 24, 2015, 06:17:08 PM
Yeah, I don't really see how I am supposed to evaluate the synth and mostly electronic instruments that dominate the track... How is it supposed to sound?  It's not like there is a reference or anything... 

Would have strongly preferred something acoustic.  Still, I think it's a pretty cool resource.

Exactly. Something like a piano trio would've been perfect. Instead they use bleep blorp crap.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: hendric0 on August 21, 2015, 12:06:24 AM
I heard Adam A5x compared to Genelec 8050A at a local mini-meet. Now that i actually heard em, they are decant speakers, but Genelecs are in a totally different league when it comes to authentic sound reproduction.  I was slightly disappointed by the Adams, in terms of over all resolution. Where you get amazing realism with Genelecs from the lows to highs, the Adams seem to have great resolution only in some narrow area 3k-4k maybe and some place higher up (some characteristic of the ribbon tweeter?). So you are missing out on holographic imaging, realism and depth of instruments and sounds (as if instruments are 2d instead of real 3d physical objects).

On the plus side. (Especially considering that the A5x are midrange, lower price monitors.)

 * Adams can do vocals. Not as physical or nuanced as Genelecs, but still, very much enjoyable. One place where the system managed to disappear.

 * Highs were decant, did not disturb in anyway, had good bite in certain areas. High hats were well resolved (not as full sounding as the other system).

 * Great build quality. Was really impressed actually.

DACs used: Soekris DAC, Yggdrasil

Music: Puscifer, Massive Attack, Pink Floyd, Ladyhawke, Archive, Tool, Hans Zimmer, Arvo Pärt.


As it has been said before, well done R2R with great speakers is something to be experienced.




Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: thegunner100 on September 11, 2015, 02:56:31 AM
Today I got to try out the LS50s at Park Avenue Audio.

600 sq ft room
Some sort of Elektra cd player > McIntosh D100 > Classe SIGMA-AMP2 > LS50

I thought that while the setup was good, it wasn't amazing considering the cost of the whole setup. It was my first time hearing any of these components, so it's hard to said what contributed to what. Plus, I was unfamiliar with all the music that was played except for Dire Strait's "Once Upon a Time in the West". I found that the LS50s had pretty good imaging and soundstaging inside the room. Treble wasn't as bright as some reviews make them out to be. Bass was kind of boomy for some reason. It had extension, but wasn't as tight as i'd hope. Dynamics were overall very good. Does anyone share my experience? Anyone tried the D100 or Classe amp before?

Hopefully I can try them again some other time with some familiar music and my own amp/dac if I can bring it in sometime. Maybe I'm just really used to the qualities that the Yggy brings to speakers and thus didn't find the LS50 setup overall amazing even though everything was pricier.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Anaxilus on September 11, 2015, 03:29:35 AM
Went to Guitar Center a week ago to audition the JBL 308 versus the Yamaha HS8. Was surprised I actually found the HS8 having clearer treble (but hollow midrange) than the JBLs and wasn't sure if the 308 was actually better than the 305 except for the bottom end, kinda different. Have to say, compared to those, the comparable Tannoys, Genelecs, Mackies, KRKs, etc., the Adams A7x crushed all of them in almost every way using their setup. Of course their price ended up being crushing too relatively speaking. I didn't really bother with the 5" stuff there other than cursory confirmation I didn't want any of it. The only real drawback was their hard L/R imaging but they were also setup up the furthest apart on the demo shelf as well.

I didn't even think the other speakers were remotely up to par with my HD800 rig tbh. The Adams were and then some. Definitely worth the money to me.

Caveat-I'd need to hear them at home to make sure no weird retailer/demo funny stuff is going on. I really though the JBLs should have sounded better than they did. Definitely not M2s.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: thegunner100 on September 11, 2015, 03:44:05 AM
Anax, you arguably have the best HD800 setup here though. These poor retail stores don't even have a yggy!
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Anaxilus on September 11, 2015, 03:59:21 AM
Maybe I should have brought my ODAC to make sure...

Actually I've heard worse kilobuck upstream gear at The Show than Guitar Center.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: mechgamer123 on September 11, 2015, 07:16:08 PM
Well, another LS50 owner here. Can't really do any direct comparisons to anything other than Pioneer's SP-BS41/21/C21 lineup which clearly isn't a fair competition. I was originally looking for ~$400 speakers to upgrade those and I listened to the DALI Zensor 1's, some PSB and Paradigm models around the same price range, and wasn't really that floored with any of them. So for shits and giggles I listened to the LS50s and thought they sounded significantly better. Went home and did some research and found a used pair from Japan for ~$700 delivered so I jumped on them. For the price I can't complain at all.

Right now I have them sitting on my desk with some blu-tack in between and that's it. They're also only about 8 inches or so away from the wall, which obviously isn't ideal but I don't think moving them forward is going to be ideal either since that'll make them way too close to my ears to form an equilateral triangle as suggested.

Any stand recommendations from people here? I'm considering Isoacoustics stands at the moment.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Azteca X on September 11, 2015, 08:15:00 PM
Have to say, compared to those, the comparable Tannoys, Genelecs, Mackies, KRKs, etc., the Adams A7x crushed all of them in almost every way using their setup..
I didn't even think the other speakers were remotely up to par with my HD800 rig tbh. The Adams were and then some. Definitely worth the money to me.

Last time I recorded they had A7X as monitors. We have some low-end Adams at my job but the A7X were just incredible. I have some Tannoys in my office (inherited them from last guy) and I'm not really a big fan. Frankly, I'm very tempted to have my home studio/office setup be something like A7x, alongside Gumby and my headphone gear, and do my serious listening there. Living room can be basic serviceable 5.1.

Anyway, Adam is no damn joke. Still curious to hear LS50 sometime but remember - the Adams also have the amp!
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Anaxilus on September 11, 2015, 08:48:11 PM
the Adams also have the amp!

Yup, and it can't be that bad if they sound that good. I'd be happy running the Yggy balanced out to A7x and call it a day.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Priidik on September 11, 2015, 08:54:56 PM
Adam A5x has nice voice reproduction, but imo this is the only aspect it was somewhat comparable to a Genelec 8050, a bit unfair comparison size and price wise though.
A7x could be better, but A3x and A5x sound almost the same to me, minus bass ofcourse.
For Yggy (Gumby?) level dac i'd go for something more resolving than A series Adam. Still they are much better than entry level Mackies, thus imo better value.   
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Anaxilus on September 11, 2015, 09:12:50 PM
A7x could be better, but A3x and A5x sound almost the same to me, minus bass ofcourse.
For Yggy (Gumby?) level dac i'd go for something more resolving than A series Adam. Still they are much better than entry level Mackies, thus imo better value.   

It is better.

What's more resolving than the A7x for the same money? I haven't heard it yet.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on September 11, 2015, 09:17:59 PM
Any stand recommendations from people here? I'm considering Isoacoustics stands at the moment.

Isoacoustics are a great option for desktop stands. There's surprisingly little out there in terms of very short stands designed for desktop use. Sound Anchors will make stands to any height, but they are expensive, and the ones that offer adjustable tilt are bulky.

The NHT stands are only about $60/pr, but they are pretty basic, fixed angle aluminum with some rubber pads on the bottom. The Ardan stands are very pretty, but also very very expensive. One that I'm not familiar with is the Zaor Miza D-stand. Their distribution in the US is limited, but you can get them here via stores like B&H Photo. I don't recommend the Auralex MoPad, really overpriced for what they are, which is basically a glorified doorstopper.

(http://www.bhphotovideo.com/images/images500x500/zaor_mz_dst_bk_che_miza_d_stands_black_1113976.jpg)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on September 11, 2015, 09:20:59 PM
It is better.

What's more resolving than the A7x for the same money? I haven't heard it yet.

I personally prefer the Neumann to the A7, but that's just me.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: RexAeterna on September 11, 2015, 10:45:31 PM
Today I got to try out the LS50s at Park Avenue Audio.

600 sq ft room
Some sort of Elektra cd player > McIntosh D100 > Classe SIGMA-AMP2 > LS50

I thought that while the setup was good, it wasn't amazing considering the cost of the whole setup. It was my first time hearing any of these components, so it's hard to said what contributed to what. Plus, I was unfamiliar with all the music that was played except for Dire Strait's "Once Upon a Time in the West". I found that the LS50s had pretty good imaging and soundstaging inside the room. Treble wasn't as bright as some reviews make them out to be. Bass was kind of boomy for some reason. It had extension, but wasn't as tight as i'd hope. Dynamics were overall very good. Does anyone share my experience? Anyone tried the D100 or Classe amp before?

Hopefully I can try them again some other time with some familiar music and my own amp/dac if I can bring it in sometime. Maybe I'm just really used to the qualities that the Yggy brings to speakers and thus didn't find the LS50 setup overall amazing even though everything was pricier.

I would avoid anything using McIntosh like a plague. Everything I heard using McIntosh gear sounded meh at best and never liked it. They're just boutique home equipment pretending to be pro gear...
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: RexAeterna on September 11, 2015, 10:53:41 PM
Went to Guitar Center a week ago to audition the JBL 308 versus the Yamaha HS8. Was surprised I actually found the HS8 having clearer treble (but hollow midrange) than the JBLs and wasn't sure if the 308 was actually better than the 305 except for the bottom end, kinda different. Have to say, compared to those, the comparable Tannoys, Genelecs, Mackies, KRKs, etc., the Adams A7x crushed all of them in almost every way using their setup. Of course their price ended up being crushing too relatively speaking. I didn't really bother with the 5" stuff there other than cursory confirmation I didn't want any of it. The only real drawback was their hard L/R imaging but they were also setup up the furthest apart on the demo shelf as well.

I didn't even think the other speakers were remotely up to par with my HD800 rig tbh. The Adams were and then some. Definitely worth the money to me.

Caveat-I'd need to hear them at home to make sure no weird retailer/demo funny stuff is going on. I really though the JBLs should have sounded better than they did. Definitely not M2s.

Thought the same thing. But I found the Yamaha's kinda bright  but, definitely cleaner than the jbls high end when I i auditioned them out of curiosity when i was at my local guitar checking out some subs and power amps there
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on September 11, 2015, 11:43:38 PM
Any stand recommendations from people here? I'm considering Isoacoustics stands at the moment.

I have a pair of Isoacoustics incoming for my Event Opals.  Will report back.  They are supposed to be good stuff, much better then a Auralex mopad or similar.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: drfindley on September 12, 2015, 06:49:31 AM
Any stand recommendations from people here? I'm considering Isoacoustics stands at the moment.
I've been using Isoacoustics with my LS50s and a speaker set before. They probably don't work anywhere near as well as speaker stands, but they make a significant difference where the bass doesn't reverb through what you set it on, which clears up the mids as well (something about the bass overpowering or canceling things out).
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Arnotts on September 12, 2015, 07:03:38 AM
I use Isoacoustics stands with my Aktimate Minis (although I intend to eventually get Neumann KH 120's). The stands actually helped pretty significantly, imo, with imaging and soundstage clarity. It all tightened up and became much more precise.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Thad E Ginathom on September 12, 2015, 10:05:39 AM
Interesting to read the experiences.

I look at the marketing and blurb for isoacoustics and think, "This is possible."

Hardly a big investment, even ordering from abroad. I like the look of them, and would put my money where my mouth is if I could only decide if I am ever going to upgrade my speakers (and thus what size to buy) or not.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Hroðulf on September 12, 2015, 11:58:13 AM
I highly recommend getting even a cheap set of studio monitor stands, they make a world of difference. Table reflections usually create a nasty mid suckout. Some studio monitors are actually tuned to compensate for mixing desk reflections, too bad they never advertise which ones.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: lmswjm on September 12, 2015, 03:10:49 PM
I really like the Isoacoustics stands as well. I did have to switch to Primacoustic's isolation pads when I got a larger desk with a higher monitor shelf. I had to shave a few inches for better height position. Both products yield a similar audible improvement. For me, better focus / clarity
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: ultrabike on September 12, 2015, 05:25:28 PM
I highly recommend getting even a cheap set of studio monitor stands, they make a world of difference. Table reflections usually create a nasty mid suckout. Some studio monitors are actually tuned to compensate for mixing desk reflections, too bad they never advertise which ones.

Yup. I got these:

http://www.amazon.com/DR-Pro-SMS1BK-Studio-Monitor/dp/B004I1FY94
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on September 12, 2015, 06:12:20 PM
I have a pair of QuickLok BS336 stands which I think are pretty good for a budget stand.  They were a bit annoying to assemble but once you get past that they are solid.  Would recommend for ~$100USD if you have a large heavy monitor and need a bigger platform.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Thad E Ginathom on September 12, 2015, 06:17:52 PM

.
I've been using Isoacoustics with my LS50s and a speaker set before. They probably don't work anywhere near as well as speaker stands ...
.

They are speaker stands!

If you mean speaker stands of the hifi sort, then they are mostly bits of furniture with the added requirement of not resonating. The isoacoustics claim to do more than that.

Off the desktop, I always avoided the issue of speaker stands by using floorstanders. On  the desktop... well, my neck is not that long  :)p15

.
I highly recommend getting even a cheap set of studio monitor stands, they make a world of difference. Table reflections usually create a nasty mid suckout. Some studio monitors are actually tuned to compensate for mixing desk reflections, too bad they never advertise which ones.
.

My speakers are around 12 inches off the desk. First, there is a shelf, about three inches up, on top of which sit things like the pre-amp, monitor, etc, and below which lives various assorted rubbish (yep: some of it probably resonates  :)p6 . It's a good thing most of my listening is on the headphones) and then there's... two piles of books.

It's a long-standing (no pun intended) tradition with me: If speakers need extra hight, I put books under them. My first ever all-my-own hifi had speakers raised off the floor on London phone directories.

Not pretty of course. Definitely doesn't resonate, though. Books are pretty dense. Who hasn't moved house and thought, "This is a nice big box, I can put lots of books in it,"  and then tried to pick it up? The only thing I ever did worse than that was a big box full of LPs.

.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: bixby on September 12, 2015, 09:36:32 PM
Here is my great all purpose desktop stand .............and they are inexpensive    8)

(http://s6.postimg.org/3wuz514cx/desktop_stand.jpg) (http://postimage.org/)


(http://s6.postimg.org/z53k2cu35/cinder_block_stand.jpg) (http://postimage.org/)

Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Thad E Ginathom on September 12, 2015, 11:24:56 PM
Very nice.

If it was me, I'd fill those holes with stuff. But I'm just messy.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Armaegis on September 13, 2015, 09:24:14 AM
Pfft, cinderblocks? I used phone books, binders and candy tins  :)p13
(click to show/hide)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: knerian on September 13, 2015, 09:33:23 AM
Pfft, cinderblocks? I used phone books, binders and candy tins  :)p13
(click to show/hide)

What pads are those on your HE-6?
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: RexAeterna on September 13, 2015, 01:52:01 PM
I always used cinder blocks or heavy concrete slabs. I have 180lbs of concret slabs under my speakers and another 200lb+ of slabs with couple layers of sprayed on rubber for my big subs. Always worked for me but, for desk monitors if I ever used them I probably make some rubber and foam combo maybe...I don't know. Never used tiny studio monitors before. Always had big heavy speakers(lightest speakers ever owned were polk monitor 10b's before I sold them off and they were bout 65lbs each). My mini monitors are usually headphones.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Armaegis on September 13, 2015, 04:58:42 PM
What pads are those on your HE-6?

Jmoney Beyer pads, discontinued long ago. I prefer them over the Audeze vegans in my config.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: thegunner100 on September 16, 2015, 02:35:04 AM
I went back to the hifi store today with my Surface Pro and my own music. I plugged it into the McIntosh D100 via USB and played away. Impressions are similar to last time, but this time I have some more specific notes.

I really noticed that the setup there was overly thick and warm sounding compared to what I was used to with both my speaker and headphone setups. I think it can be attributed to the McIntosh house sound (The D100 is acting as dac/pre-amp), based on what I've read. Is it true that McIntoshes tend to be warm sounding?

I noticed that the treble was somewhat rolled off. The sibilance in Hotel California is somewhat masked by the setup. In addition, the setup was somewhat lacking in dynamics. There weren't huge shifts in volume as expected in some of my tracks. It was overall just kind of soft sounding. Transients were somewhat smeared and slow (Guitar struts in various tracks). Drums hits were not tight and slow to decay. Instruments didn't seem to just "pop" out and fade like what I'm used to with the Yggy. Is that due to a lack of a black background, poor transients, and slow decay?

That's not to say that there weren't any positives to the system. The LS50s filled up the room pretty well and had good soundstaging for their size. One example is on Dogs by Pink Floyd (Animals 2011 remaster): the howls and barks from the dogs seemed to come from outside the boundaries of the speakers. Again from my previous post, imaging was pretty good... BUT, I think it was really held back by the lush sound.

I don't really think that the LS50s were tuned this way, based on many accounts of how they sound. The McIntosh D100 and Classe Sigma AMP2 seem to be a poor match for the LS50s imo, based on my own preferences for how a speaker or even a headphone setup should sound. Of course, it's hard to say which part of the system contributed to what I was hearing but at the very least if I'm correct about the McIntosh house sound, then I have a better idea of the whole system. I can understand that a lot of people may want this forgiving, lush sound but to make an analogy that's often used here: why gimp a hd800 with an overly warm and unresolving amp (violectric amps for example)? It just doesn't make sense to me. I'd love to give the LS50s another chance, but lugging my Yggy and Virtue to the store would take too much work. My best bet would be taking the risk and buying them sometime down the line.

Hopefully this post was somewhat coherent. Please correct me if I used some of these audio terms wrong.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Cos on September 16, 2015, 03:46:14 AM
Looks like some people agitate for an LS50 active edition, probably named LS 55 or something similar actually:
http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/09/think-about-the-future-an-active-kef-ls50-loudspeaker/ (http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/09/think-about-the-future-an-active-kef-ls50-loudspeaker/)
Interesting product if it ever comes to life: cheaper than a good amp and passive speakers, optimized amp, and less real estate taken on the desk.

In the meanwhile I have been eyeing the coaxial offerings from equator audio - did any of the Pirates try them?
http://www.equatoraudio.com/ (http://www.equatoraudio.com/)
They received accolades from the recording industry for their affordable and innovative D5. The man behind the company, Ted Keffalo, is a veteran in this domain with excellent track of innovative and quality products. Most products on the site are out of stock though- think they may be up to something- either strong demand of their wares or announcing new versions.

For people looking for desktop speakers, https://www.massdrop.com/home (https://www.massdrop.com/home) has a good deal on Adam F7. At less than half the price of A7x and very close behind in quality they may be a great choice.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: lmswjm on September 16, 2015, 06:21:08 AM
One of these days I'd like to give one of those Equator Q models a spin
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Hroðulf on September 16, 2015, 06:40:04 AM
Looks like some people agitate for an LS50 active edition, probably named LS 55 or something similar actually:
http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/09/think-about-the-future-an-active-kef-ls50-loudspeaker/ (http://www.digitalaudioreview.net/2015/09/think-about-the-future-an-active-kef-ls50-loudspeaker/)
Interesting product if it ever comes to life: cheaper than a good amp and passive speakers, optimized amp, and less real estate taken on the desk.

In the meanwhile I have been eyeing the coaxial offerings from equator audio - did any of the Pirates try them?
http://www.equatoraudio.com/ (http://www.equatoraudio.com/)
They received accolades from the recording industry for their affordable and innovative D5. The man behind the company, Ted Keffalo, is a veteran in this domain with excellent track of innovative and quality products. Most products on the site are out of stock though- think they may be up to something- either strong demand of their wares or announcing new versions.

For people looking for desktop speakers, https://www.massdrop.com/home (https://www.massdrop.com/home) has a good deal on Adam F7. At less than half the price of A7x and very close behind in quality they may be a great choice.

There is absolutely no space inside the existing cabinets. I've taken them apart once and know that you can barely stick a beercan in there. Either they make a backpack type of amp module or redesign the cabs.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: DaveBSC on September 16, 2015, 06:44:51 PM
There is the X300A which at least gives you an actively powered KEF Uni-Q driver, but it's obviously not the same speaker.

(http://2c.zol-img.com.cn/product/109_800x600/834/ceoaFCvafij72.jpg)
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: Chris F on September 23, 2015, 06:38:20 PM
Got the IsoAcoustics in and have had them under the Opals for about a week now.  They clean up the bass a lot; very audible improvement and you can see it in the room measurement as well.
Title: Re: $1000± for mini monitors…
Post by: lmswjm on September 30, 2015, 09:45:41 PM
Re: Equator Audio

The D5 & D8's models are being updated, that's why there's no stock showing right now. I'm going to be giving the Q12's a shot. Equator just ebay'd an open box pair for almost half off.

I love my PSI Audio A17's for near/midfield. However, I couldn't resist 12" drivers w/ 700 watts of power for a bigger room for mid/far field listening. Can't wait to hear drums & bass reproduction there.  :boom: