I don't criticize the sound for the tamed treble, I think the HE-6 is bright to a fault. I felt your HE-6 pulled me into the sound at an odd place, it might have just been because they were out of phase. I think you have the best HE-6 so far, but maybe it's just not the right headphone for me. That said, if there is supposed to be air and yours don't have it that would be an error IMO even if it's less pleasurable, but I couldn't hear well enough at the meet and I don't know well enough in general to make that assessment.